The academics did not fare well in Re Avanti Communications Ltd (in admin) [2023] EWHC 940 (Ch). Edwin Johnson J determined that the security in issue was fixed not floating but not without finding himself in respectful disagreement with Beale Bridge Goode (if only by book title) Gullifer and Worthington. It is perhaps predictable that one of us might rush to a defence. I hesitated appreciating that judges are not similarly free. But the issue is important and the approach advocated in Avanti appears with the greatest respect and even greater admiration for the unravelling of security documents needed in that case to be unsupported by the cases and unworkable in practice. In short even if the answer is right (space prevents that being addressed here) the means of reaching it is surely not. What follows...