This article, the second of two (see ‘Risk elimination by legislating: the limits of the law and challenges of reality’ (2023) 5 JIBFL 287) looking at significant policy making challenges, argues that too much recent legislation and regulation is of poor quality, often developed with good intentions but in silos, without effective consultation, proportionality or consistent principle. Too much is created so policy makers can be seen to have “done something” when it will not address the real goals. The article proposes possible solutions, including changing policy maker incentives and the creation of a new Parliamentary Select Committee to introduce accountability for legislative and regulatory outcomes, comparable to spending accountability.